What the 2026 Midterms Results Mean for Tariffs and Canada-U.S. Relations

Share this:

The midterms were highly anticipated as many policy analysts believed that significant gains made by the Democrats could result in a weaker President. In Canada, many saw the run-up to the midterms as a wild-card period that could have significant impacts on the Canada-U.S. relationship and future negotiations. While the lead-up to the midterms did have some impacts on the Canadian tariffs, specifically in terms of the Section 338 tariff scope adjustment announced on October 23, the larger impacts of the new Senate and House will be seen over the coming two years.  

The new Congress will take their seats in January 2027, at which time the first 100 days will set the expectations for the next two years. In these first 100 days, some policy experts are expecting that the Democrats will put forward numerous bills with specific language in order to force votes. The bills put forward will not be designed to pass but will rather be designed to find “friendly” Republicans who may be willing to vote with the Democrats should they need to overcome a veto.  

IMPACTS ON FOREIGN AND TRADE POLICY 

While Congress can pass legislation, there are concerns that the Democrats will be slightly reserved when it comes to passing legislation that would impact the President’s authority over foreign policy. Historically, Congress has been hesitant to intervene in matters of foreign policy, and many expect that this new makeup of Congress will follow suit.  

In terms of U.S. trade policy, we expect it to largely remain the same, as this policy is set by the Administration and is an extension of foreign policy. The U.S. Administration’s trade policy agenda is designed to reshore and rebuild American manufacturing, achieve greater market access opportunities for U.S. goods, and strategically rebalance the U.S.-China economic relationship to reduce American dependency on Chinese imports. Even though some of the actions the Administration has taken to enforce the trade policy are opposed to by the Democrats, the policy at its base largely aligns with the Democrats’ trade objectives.     

However, one area where Congress may exert some control over the U.S. trade policy is via the United States Trade Representative (USTR), who is answerable to Congress. The USTR has largely sidestepped Congress, providing only the necessary reports required under law. We expect to see the USTR called into Congress, where he will be questioned on the mechanics of decisions and transparency.  

IMPACTS ON CANADA-U.S. RELATIONS 

It is expected that some of the legislation put forward in the first 100 days of the new Congress will be related to the tariffs on Canada. The Democrats have already introduced symbolic legislation under the current sitting calling for an end to tariffs on Canada, and we expect to see similar legislation again. The key, however, will be whether this legislation is passed or continues to be introduced in a symbolic manner.  

Outside of Congress, it is possible that there will be a shuffling in the Administration. A shuffle could be beneficial for Canada-U.S. negotiations and CUSMA discussions if certain representatives who cause negotiation disruptions, such as Howard Lutnick, are removed from their roles. However, with the Democrats controlling the Senate, it will be more difficult to have candidates approved, making a shuffle less palatable to the administration. At this time, the Administration has not indicated that it intends to shuffle. 

Should we expect the results of the midterms to have any impact on the tariffs currently levied on Canada? 

To date, the U.S. Administration has enacted tariffs under the authorities that grant it the ability to bypass Congress. This includes the IEEPA tariffs that were levied from March 2025 until February 2026; the Section 122 tariffs that were levied from January until July 2026, as well as the current tariffs levied under the Section 301, Section 232, and Section 338 authorities. We expect that the Administration will continue to levy tariffs under authorities that bypass Congress, even as some American businesses are challenging the use of such authority in court, making the overall impact of the midterms on Canadian tariffs minimal.  

How will this impact the upcoming review of the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement? 

The 2027 CUSMA Review is scheduled for July 1, at which point Canada, the U.S., and Mexico can either pledge to an extension of the agreement beyond 2036 or continue the annual review cycle. The U.S. CUSMA review process is run by the USTR, who is an appointed official and answerable to Congress. Currently, the USTR has initiated consultations for the 2027 CUSMA review, signalling that he is preparing for the July 1 meeting.  

Congress would only be required to engage on CUSMA if the U.S. decides to withdraw from the agreement. In this case, Congress would need to repeal the implementing legislation in order for the U.S. to withdraw from the agreement. However, this seems unlikely, as the USTR has not expressed an interest in leaving CUSMA at this time and instead is aiming to secure bilateral agreements with Canada and Mexico that would layer on top of the agreement. It is unclear whether the Administration would seek congressional approval on these bilateral agreements or if it would sidestep Congress as it has with other agreements with countries such as the UK, Japan, and South Korea.  

Overall, there are no immediate concerns that a change in the makeup of Congress would negatively impact the CUSMA review.  

Is it possible that there will be tariff-free trade between Canada and the U.S.? 

A tariff-free trade deal between Canada and the U.S. seems extremely unlikely, despite the new makeup of Congress. As noted above, U.S. trade policy is designed to reshore and rebuild American manufacturing while also addressing trade imbalances. For this reason, the U.S. has been very forthcoming about the reality that tariffs will be a part of any trade deal that they negotiate. The Government of Canada has already begun preparing Canadian businesses for the possibility that tariffs will remain between Canada and the U.S. for the foreseeable future, even in the event that a bilateral/sectoral deal is reached.  

Since President Trump took office in January 2025, we have been steadily moving towards “managed trade” in North America. This means that we will not return to “free trade” as it was and instead should expect a new trading environment to take shape for the foreseeable future. This includes some tariffs, as well as a growing use of tariff rate quotas (TRQs) to allow agreed-upon volumes of goods to enter both countries at zero or low tariffs; any volumes above the agreed-upon ones would then be subject to higher, more prohibitive tariffs.   

It is important to note that on Tuesday, the Prime Minister noted that negotiations with the U.S. were picking up steam following the call between the Prime Minister and President Trump last weekend. These negotiations, if successful, will likely lead to a form of tariff reduction. 

Looking Ahead: What Wellington Advocacy is Watching 

As is the case in every election, midterms are just the starting point for the next two years. Elected officials will now be given the chance to carry out their campaign promises and attempt to make their mark on Washington. For the next couple of months, Wellington Advocacy will be monitoring the actions in Washington to gain a better understanding of how the U.S. direction following midterms may impact Canada.  

WHAT STEPHEN DE BOER IS WATCHING 

Strategic Advisory Board member Stephen de Boer, who served as Canada’s Ambassador to the World Trade Organization and Foreign Affairs Advisor to the Prime Minister, expects Congress to move quickly on affordability issues, potentially building bipartisan support to put pressure on the Administration to limit new tariffs and roll back some existing ones, particularly on those affecting Canada. As such, Stephen will be watching whether this congressional pressure leads the Administration to ease tariffs on key Canadian sectors such as automobiles and aluminum.   

The U.S. has previously indicated that the domestic capacity for producing aluminum is not meeting the needs of the market and has made Section 232 tariff modifications accordingly. As the cost of living continues to skyrocket in the U.S., there is potential for Congress to take action on the aluminum tariffs in an effort to tackle affordability.   

Similarly, the auto sector is seeing widespread disruption due to the tariffs. In Michigan, a key auto manufacturing state, Canadian tariffs were a significant concern in the election, due to associated jobs. It is possible that we will see Congress pass some legislation related to the auto sector tariffs in an effort to protect manufacturing jobs in auto states and ease affordability concerns.  

WHAT JAMES RAJOTTE IS WATCHING 

Strategic Advisory Board member James Rajotte, who served as Alberta’s Senior Representative to the United States, is watching how the Democratic leadership in the House and the Senate manage their dual priorities of addressing the affordability concerns of Americans and holding the Trump Administration to account. 

In addition to addressing these dual priorities, James will look at how the Democratic leadership, particularly incoming Speaker Jeffries, will manage the situation between more traditional Democrats, such as those in the “Problem Solvers Caucus,” and the more progressive wing of the party, the Democratic Socialists. The progressive wing had much of the energy leading into the midterms, but the Democrats did win in strong “Republican” areas and thus will need to tack to the centre if they wish to retain these seats going forward. Former Speaker Nancy Pelosi effectively managed that coalition during her tenure. 

Specifically, James will be watching who gets which chair positions, given the power of committees in the American system, as this will have a significant impact on oversight hearings. The chair controls the questions posed to administrative officials, and as such, has the opportunity to put as much (or as little) pressure on Administration officials as they deem necessary. Given the corruption and other issues currently present in the Administration, the Democrats will likely feel a responsibility to hold the officials to account. 

James is not expecting any large-scale agreements in the new Session on items like deficit reduction or immigration, but he will be interested to see how and where the President attempts to work with the new Congress on issues related to affordability. He has in the past reached out to some Democratic members (like Senator Elizabeth Warren) on certain issues and is not a traditional or ideological Republican, so may be open to making a deal. Given that the Democrats won both Houses handily, they will have to show some action on affordability and will need the President to agree to some measures. 

WHAT WELLINGTON ADVOCACY’S TRADE PRACTICE IS WATCHING 

Wellington Advocacy’s trade practice is watching the reaction from the U.S. Administration and Embassy to Canada. Leading up to the midterms, Ambassador Hoekstra and Special Counsel Navarro made several comments regarding Canadian interference in the U.S. elections, some of which included tariff threats. Wellington Advocacy will continue to monitor U.S. comments regarding the election and evaluate whether there is a threat to Canada-U.S. relations following the election results.  

Wellington Advocacy will also be watching the legislation put forward in the first 100 days of the new Congress to evaluate the position the U.S. has on both Canada and China. China is one issue where the Democrats and Republicans generally see eye-to-eye; both parties want to reduce dependence on the market. We expect that the majority of trade legislation passed by Congress will hinge on China and restricting market access. This position could have significant impacts on Canada as it attempts to diversify trading relationships while also rebuilding the relationship with the United States. The U.S. has already indicated that a unified approach to China is a high priority for negotiations with its CUSMA partners, and additional legislation may increase the stakes of policy alignment.  

Next Steps for Businesses 

The U.S. midterms saw a “blue tsunami”, with the Democrats securing significant gains. While Congress does not typically exercise significant authority over foreign and trade policy, there remain opportunities for Congress to impact U.S. trade policy through oversight hearings and legislation. Once the new Congress takes its seats, we expect the first 100 days to be indicative of the direction and priorities for Congress for the next two years.  

What remains crucial, regardless of the makeup of Congress, is for businesses to continue to engage on both sides of the border. Negotiators use the inputs of stakeholders to inform their positions, and businesses must continue to take the opportunity to meet with U.S. and Canadian officials and highlight the harms that tariffs are having on both sides of the border. Wellington Advocacy remains available to support businesses engaging with the Canadian government on all trade and tariff-related issues, from narrative development and stakeholder mapping to execution.  



We create value by shaping government policy and public opinion.